For over a year now, I have pondered the question, "Do I want a drift boat or a raft?" I have spent a little time around each and have enjoyed my experiences in both. Ideally, I would like to have one of each, but financially, that's not a possibility right now. In the end, there is no right answer. It is a situational decision so let's look at the situation. So I need to make a choice. Let's look at some pros and cons but let's take a step further. Let's look at this through the lens of a Midwest guy that lives 100 miles away from Ozark streams.
Drift boats have a special place in my heart. To me, they are fly fishing icons. They are comfortable, stable, and fairly tough. There is room for storage and a little room to walk around. They can be tough (aluminum) a little fragile (fiberglass) or somewhere in between (wood). They are more expensive than rafts but in my opinion, it's because they are worth it.
Rafts on the other hand are less expensive and easier to store. They handle shallow water situations a little better in the sense that they need less water to float. On the other hand, a drift boat will probably bounce off rocks and take a little damage. A drift boat might tear which is immensely more problematic. Rafts are lighter and can get a person into less accessible areas such as areas that don't have boat ramps.
I have wrestled with this decision for a long time and I'm leaning towards a raft. I have really enjoyed my experiences with Ryan Walker and chasing smallmouth bass down Ozark streams. I want to do more of that in the future but I also want to drift places like the Niangua River for trout took. Ozarks streams seem to be better suited for rafts, especially during low flows. On the other hand, I sure would like to guide on Lake Taneycomo one day. Fly fishing out of a drift boat on that lake is as close to fishing big western trout streams, like the North Platte, as I will typically get.
So let's zoom a little further out at look at my options that are closer to home. Putting a raft on a farm pond or small lake sure would be easier than a drift boat. While a drift boat would be more comfortable, the issues that arise with launching a drift boat without a ramp, while not impossible, could be problematic. I can't exactly carry a drift boat through an agriculture field. Carrying a drift boat would stink, but it is possible.
When it comes to fishing lakes like Watkins Mill, Lake Jacomo, or other smaller lakes, the point is moot point. I have a jon boat for that but if I wanted to take a couple of folks out on those lakes, a drift boat would be more comfortable. On the other hand, I don't have the garage space, nor desire, to store a drift boat. I could, however, store a raft on the floor, under my jon boat.
So while I want a drift boat for so many reasons, a raft seems like the right choice for me right now...I think. I'm hesitant to get a raft though because there just so much I don't know about them. What happens if I pop an air chamber? How much air to I put in one? What size of trailer to I need to haul one? What kind of pump should I get? How do I minimize wear and tear to make a raft last as long as possible? How do I fix a hole? Most of these problems are nonexistent with drift boats.
Now you're probably thinking one of two things. One, "This guy overanalyzes things." Or maybe you are thinking, "This guy sure is putting a lot of thought into making a logical choice." I'm hopeful that I am somewhere between the two but ultimately, I just want to get the right tool for the job and make the best financial decision. While a decision has been looming for quite awhile, I believe that I am closer to committing to a choice and making a purchase soon. Stay tuned for more. This story ain't over!